release_criteria/r9/9.0_qa_testing_go_no_go.md

@@ -19,8 +19,8 @@ As a reminder, the objective of a release (major or minor) is to provide a solid
 
 | Category          | Proportion        | Remaining Items |
 | ----------------- | ----------------- | --------------- |
-| TO_CONFIRM        |   0 / 29 (0%)     |                 |
+| TO_CONFIRM        |   1 / 29 (3%)     | Firmware RAID   |
-| PASS              |   0 / 29 (0%)     |                 |
+| PASS              |   28/ 29 (97%)    |                 |
 | FAIL_NON_BLOCKING |   0 / 29 (0%)     |                 |
 | FAIL_BLOCKING     |   0 / 29 (0%)     |                 |
 
@@ -52,15 +52,15 @@ Examples...
 
 ## Initialization Requirements
 
--   Release-blocking images must boot - PASS - (@neil, @atomicturtle)
+-   Release-blocking images must boot - PASS - (@neil, @atomicturtle, @lumarel)
--   Optical Media Requirements - PASS - (@atomicturtle)
+-   Optical Media Requirements - PASS - (@neil)
 -   Basic Graphics Mode behaviors - PASS - (@tcooper, virt only, manual)
 -   No Broken Packages - PASS - (@tcooper, scripted, manual)
--   Repositories Must Match Upstream - TO_CONFIRM - (@tcooper, manual)
+-   Repositories Must Match Upstream - PASS - (@tcooper, manual)
 -   Debranding - PASS - (@tcooper, scripted, manual)
 -   Media Consistency Verification - PASS - (@tcooper, scripted, manual)
 -   Packages and Installer Sources - PASS - (@lumarel, semi-automatic, openQA test)
--   NAS (Network Attached Storage) - TO_CONFIRM - (@lumarel?, semi-automatic, openQA dual-host test)
+-   NAS (Network Attached Storage) - PASS - (@stack, manual)
 -   Installation Interfaces - PASS - (@lumarel, @raktajino, @tcooper, semi-automatic, openQA, @atomicturtle, manual?, SCAP)
 -   Minimal Installation - PASS - (@lumarel, @raktajino, @tcooper, semi-automatic , openQA)
 -   Kickstart Installation - PASS - (@label, @tcooper, manual, createhdds)
@@ -74,7 +74,7 @@ Examples...
 
 
 ## Cloud Image Requirements
--   Images Published to Cloud Providers - FAIL_NON_BLOCKING - (@neil)
+-   Images Published to Cloud Providers - PASS - (@neil)
 
 
 ## Post-Installation Requirements

release_criteria/r9/9.0_qa_testing_summary.md

@@ -28,20 +28,7 @@ This document will record a summary of all QA and Testing results for {{ rc.prod
 This is a list of items that are being INVESTIGATEd further before being assigned a PASS, FAIL, NOTABUG or UPSTREAM status.
 PLEASE add your MM handle if you are working on this item to minimize duplication of work. More than one handle is allowed but please communicate.
 
-- QA:Testcase Basic Graphics Mode                          - [INVESTIGATE] - @tcooper
+- QA:Testcase Firmware RAID                        - [INVESTIGATE] - @neil
-- QA:Testcase Boot Methods Boot Iso                        - [INVESTIGATE] - @neil
-- QA:Testcase Boot Methods DVD                             - [INVESTIGATE] - @neil
-- QA:Testcase Debranding                                   - [INVESTIGATE] - @tcooper
-- QA:Testcase Media Consistency Verification               - [INVESTIGATE] - @tcooper
-- QA:Testcase Media File Conflicts                         - [INVESTIGATE] - @tcooper
-- QA:Testcase Media File Conflicts                         - [INVESTIGATE] - @tcooper
-- QA:Testcase Media File Conflicts                         - [INVESTIGATE] - @tcooper
-- QA:Testcase Media File Conflicts                         - [INVESTIGATE] - @tcooper
-- QA:Testcase Media Repoclosure                            - [INVESTIGATE] - @tcooper
-- QA:Testcase Storage Volume Resize                        - [INVESTIGATE] - @raktajino
-- QA:Testcase Update Image                                 - [INVESTIGATE] - @raktajino
-- QA:Testcase boot/install minimal x86_64 over DVD/Bluray  - [INVESTIGATE] - @atomicturtle
-- QA:Testcase_Mediacheck                                   - [INVESTIGATE] - @tcooper
 
 ## UPSTREAM
 This is a list of items that have been verified to be replicated UPSTREAM in RHEL {{ rc.9 }} and/or are described clearly in the RHEL 9 Release Notes.
@@ -52,16 +39,76 @@ This is a list of items that have been verified to be replicated UPSTREAM in RHE
 This is a list of items that have been verified to FAIL the QA:Testcase. In addition to recording who did the test please indicate if the item is BLOCKING release or not.
 
 - QA:Testcase_Some_Testcase                                - [FAIL] - @your_mm_handle - <brief_description>
+- RC1 -  The blue side banner  background at the left side of the Anaconda installer display is not displaying correctly in virt-viewer. [minor BUG] - @alangm
 
 ## NOTABUG
 This is a list of items that have been verified as less than optimal but are expected and NOTABUG.
 
-- QA:Testcase_Some_Testcase                                - [NOTABUG] - @your_mm_handle - <brief_description>
+- QA:Testcase Basic Graphics Mode                             - [DEPRICATED]      - @tcooper
 
 ## PASS
 This is a list of item that have been verified as PASSing the QA:Testcase named (or proposed).
 
-- QA:Testcase_Some_Testcase                                - [PASS] - @your_mm_handle - <brief_description>
+- QA:Testcase_Debranding - [PASS] - @tcooper - preliminary pass based on Peridot yumrepofs - https://rpa.st/PZKA
+- RC1 - QA:Testcase System Services - [PASS] - @lumarel - tested with boot-iso and every base environment
+- RC1 - Basic Installs - [PASS] - @lumarel - Installs of all base environments on x86_64 without additional optional package groups
+- RC1 - QA:Testcase Packages and Installer Sources - [PASS] - @raktajino - tested against RC1-boot-iso in openQA, all package sets pass.
+- RC1 - QA:Testcase GNOME UI Functionality - [PASS] - @lumarel - Nothing to mention
+- RC1 - QA:Testcase SELinux Errors on Server - [PASS] - @lumarel - no errors
+- RC1 - QA:Testcase SELinux Errors on Desktop- [PASS] - @lumarel - no errors
+- RC1 - QA:Testcase Artwork and Assets - [PASS] - @lumarel - everything looks correct
+- RC1 - QA:Testcase Minimal Installation - [PASS] - @raktajino - nothing to report
+- RC1 - QA: Testcase Boot Methods Boot Iso - [PASS] - @alangm - minimal system, graphical server & basic workstation - nothing to report except as above ^^^
+- RC1 - Minimal install on QEMU/KVM passing - [PASS] - @boris - reboot takes slightly longer on the first reboot
+- RC1 - Repo Health Check - [PASS] - @lumarel - sqlite database files for repo metadata is missing up to now, which will hinder some applications from syncing the sources - are implemented
+- RC1 - Repo Health Check - [PASS] - @lumarel - metadata signing not implemented up to now - looks to be implemented as well now
+- RC1 - Repo Health Check - [PASS] - @lumarel - Repos look good now excl. BaseOS of aarch64, ppc64le, s390x, where the boot image is missing, which is referenced in the .treeinfo
+- RC1 - Redesign looks to be broken (Post-Install error, effects some of the install groups) - [PASS] - @lumarel
+- RC1 - Workstation install with known pesign bug - [PASS] - @alangm - error window  "Exit Installer" button froze Anaconda instead of exit so had to initiate shutdown from cockpit - @lumarel - fixed!
+- RC1 - Building packages with mock - [PASS] - @hbjy - building works with the mock config from sokels' repo (will be upstreamed for release)
+- RC1 - Install apache + mariadb-server - [PASS] - @sspencerwire - mariadb-secure-installation works, nextcloud install on top as well
+- RC1 - Install works on macOS M1 - [PASS] - @netwaze, @gardo984, @jordan_c
+- RC1 - Install on baremetal went well - [PASS] - @alangm - on a Dell T630
+- RC1 - Install went well - [PASS] - @kars88 - there was some flickering during the install
+- RC1.1 dvd - STIG security - [PASS] - @atomicturtle - packages were not complete in RC1 dvd, but are now in RC1.1
+- RC1.1 - Basic installs work - [PASS] - @mkahric - Virtualbox on Windows (UEFI w/o SB), Workstation Player on Windows (UEFI w/ SB), Hyper-V (UEFI w/ SB)
+- RC1.1 - docker installation with ansible works - [PASS] - @gardo984
+- RC1 - Repo Health Check - [PASS] - @lumarel - all repos (x86_64, aarch64, ppc64le, s390x) look good now, all metadata is healthy and all package checksums match
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase Multimonitor Setup - [PASS] - @lumarel - looks good
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase Artwork and Assets - [PASS] - @lumarel - no issues found
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase GNOME UI Functionality - [PASS] - @lumarel - everything behaves as it should
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase SELinux Errors on Desktop - [PASS] - @lumarel - After an hour of usage no errors
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase Keyboard Layout - [PASS] - @lumarel - OpenQA tests and manual tests show normal behavior
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase SELinux Errors on Server - [PASS] - @lumarel - after more than an hour of runtime with several installs and application setups (missing, Katello bootstrap, which once brought some SELinux errors)
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase System Services - [PASS] - @lumarel - no errors
+- RC1.1 - QA: Testcase Installation Interfaces - [PASS] - @raktajino - failures on the Welcome Tour screen because we haven't handled it yet. Everything else seems good.
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase Installer Help - [PASS] - @raktajino  - no errors
+- RC1.1 - QA: Testcase Disk Layouts - [PASS] - @raktajino - Assorted post-install failures due to either mismatch between console login and GUI login or unhandled Welcome Tour.
+- RC1.1 - QA: Testcase Kickstart Installation - [PASS] - @raktajino - Executed manually with virt-install. Nothing to report.
+- RC1.1 - QA: Testcase Update Image - [PASS] - @raktajino - failure on _console_wait_login as the GUI login screen is displayed. Update image is applied as expected.
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase VNC Graphics Mode - [PASS] - @tcooper
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase Basic Package installs - [PASS] - @lumarel - All package sets and services tested which are currently on the blocking list
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase Application Functionality - [PASS] - @lumarel - everything looks good
+- RC1/RC1.1 - QA:Testcase_Mediacheck - [PASS] - @tcooper
+- RC1/RC1.1 - QA:Testcase Media Consistency Verification - [PASS] - @tcooper
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase Media Repoclosure - [PASS] - @tcooper
+- RC1.1 - QA:Testcase Media File Conflicts - [PASS] - @tcooper
+- RC1.1 - QA: Testcase Bootloader Disk Selection - [PASS] - @raktajino
+- RC1.1 - QA: Testcase Installer Translations - [PASS] - @raktajino
+- RC1.1 - QA: Testcase Network Attached Storage - [PASS] - @Stack
+- QA: Testcase Boot Methods Boot ISO - [PASS] - all of us <3
+- QA: Testcase Boot Methods DVD - [PASS] - todos nosotros <3
+- QA:Testcase Cloud Images Published - [PASS] - @neil
+- QA:Testcase Storage Volume Resize - [PASS] - @raktajino, @tcooper
+- QA:Testcase Repocompare - [PASS] - @tcooper
+- QA:Testcase Basic install boot final ISO - [PASS] - @lumarel
+- QA:Testcase Basic install minimal final ISO - [PASS] - @lumarel
+- QA:Testcase Basic installs dvd final ISO - [PASS] - @lumarel - install of every base environment + custom operating system with all options enabled
+- OpenQA tests with final ISOs - [PASS] - @lumarel - boot-iso 2/2 | minimal-iso 2/2 | minimal 22/26 (failing are all false-positive) | server 21/26 (failing are all false-positive) | package-set 5/5 | workstation 17/26 (failing are all false-positive) | graphical-server 17/26 (failing are all false-positive) | universal 34/43 (failing are all false-positive)
+- QA:Testcase Minimal Installation - [PASS] - @neil
 
 ## OTHER NOTABLE ITEMS
-
+- QA:Testcase Module Streams - @lumarel - 9.0 currently does not have any Stream metadata and only the base Streams
+- Repo Health Check - @lumarel - yumrepofs is not sending content lengths, which make syncing with Katello impossible
+- Missing package in package group additional-devel - @stack - dnf -y group install additional-devel: No match for group package "hmaccalc" - this is an old EL bug
+- Hosting a nfs server in macOS, and using that in Virtualbox for OpenQA shares is a pain - @tcooper